I have read all the books and liked all the movies. I thought the last movie got the tone right and this one did as well. The movie is good and handles the darkness (Dumbledore) and light (girls) very well. The only annoying thing is the changes from the book that were not needed. Some changes make sense and you can't keep everything, but other changes are just stupid or lazy. I enjoyed it a lot, but wish they would stop making small changes for no reason.