well.. i agree that it was an okay movie.. for someone who read the book and can still appreciate it for a movie was a little disappointed. it seemed a little disjointed and cut. when harry potter discovered it was a fake he simply said that it was a fake. they didnt even focus on the initials for too long.. and the castle fight?? where was that.. that really does make the action for the book.. and it shouldve been included because it just looked like everyone woke up when they heard one body fall down off a tower. plus, they settled for a bland hopeful ending instead of going with the grand finale funeral ending.. i loved it because the movie did a great job of getting all the main plots out but for the actual storytelling.. 6 outta 10