This movie was a bit far-fetched for me. I cocked my head a ton and had a great many moments where I was wondering, "WTF?"
I love Indy and I love Marion. I missed Marcus and Dear Old Dad. Shia was decent, but not as strong a performance as he had in Disturbia (which I think he excelled in) and Cate Blanchett was too much of a parody for me to even start to take seriously.
Now that I've listed all my grievances, Indy will always be one of my favorite movie franchises. The actions is always good and the dialog cheesy (which is why I love it so much.)
Can't wait to see if Shia puts on dad's hat in the next one...