This was an extremely well done movie. I especially appreciated the reasoned dialog of David Berlinski, Stephen Meyer, Michael Egnor. P.Z. Myers, Dawkins, Scott, Shermer were just creepy while Provine appeared to be nothing less than psychotic. We took the kids (ages 12 and 14) and they loved it, too. The movie has inspired conversations about what to study in college, evil, Nazism, truth, Malthus, the holocaust, and other topics. It created a great enthusiasm for science in the kids and it deserves 5 stars for that alone.