This movie was well shot, some good acting (and some acting that left something to be desired). The storyline for the most was pretty solid, a few holes in though - what happened to young James T and the officer in Iowa?, the whole tension between Lt Uhura and Spock, seems contrary to the Original TV show, so in my opinion a little weak (streched).
I watched it in 'IMAX'. Overall though I would see it again but maybe not on IMAX.