Twilight Eclispe was an excellent flim. As a GUY and somone who has read all four books with my wife I felt David Slade did an excellent job keeping to the books story line. The romance was just right (not to heavy and not to dorky) and the action was really intense. The battle was something that I always thought it would be, just one big brawl. My only thing is that it might be a little too intense for the younger twilight fans ( the 8-11 range). Overall kick ass movie and people who are fans will keep seeing all summer long and for poeple who havent seen a twilight movie yet, what are you waiting for, go see eclipse