I have read the series and this movie gave me exactly what I had pictured / wanted from the book. It was perfectly done and I was very invested in it. The bad reviews and ratings are almost all from older men...who I would bet have not read the books. So, for those in the "Bitter Barn, bailing their Hate Hay"...get over it. Just b/c your girlfriend was screaming at the screen at Rob's brooding stare or TL's 8 pack, doesn't make it a bad film. A strong thumbs up.