Letters to Juliet is a romantic comedy set in Italy with great scenery and interesting story line. Redgrave is great in her role as is Amanda Seyfried. Story or story in story suffers form being too predictable in its outcomes and sugar coating the ending. Could have been a great movie if the director ended it with a repeat of the central story with the two newly found lovers - at least it could have had a bit a real life. In the film, the ending was all too predictable and, without a twist, left no surprises. Story suffers at times from failing ot capture the spark or fire that grows between Seyfried and Egan. Pieces are there, but is unconvincing, even in the end. I give a solid good watch (3*) and fun flick, but it fails to be a great movie. It is frustrating since the potential is there to have been a great movie with better directing and being less set on the happy ending.