I thought the movie rocked, mostly because of Shia LaBeouf. Mutt Williams was a cutie, but I think he could have been a total cardboard cutout without Shia's acting ability. Shia's tears and great line deliveries beefed up a pretty flat-as-written role. I really hope Mutt Williams ends up being popular enough with the fans to carry on his own franchise (hopefully with Indy at least playing a sort of Sean Connery role). Harrison Ford did a nice job as Indy, too. He was a much softer character, but you can blame the scriptwriters for that, and I actually kind of liked it. I didn't find it entirely believable, though, that he'd just settle down with Marion so fast and that he, Marion and Mutt would become an insta-family. I liked it, and I thought it was an interesting twist that they didn't do the cliched "we can't stand each other until the very end!" bit, but I wish the writers had made it a bit more believable. I do think the main storyline was a bit strange, but it never lost me. For the record, Last Crusade is still my favorite, but this is now my second favorite (then Raiders). Looking forward to more Indy flicks!