I read the 1st 2 books but not this one so can't compare the transition, but I did like this movie better than the 1st 2. Lots of improvements, though still not a Kristen Stewart fan. I was glad to see more info. about the history of some of the Cullens, especially Jasper. I did not care for the actress who played Victoria, the 1st one was awesome. The movie is definately a teen girl love triangle type movie and they will love it, but even as a middle aged woman I still enjoy the series so far. Sorry everyone, but I'm definately "Team Jacob". Edward is just a little too melodramatic for me. Overall the series is great, I will read the book, Eclipse, and look forward to Breaking Dawn.