As someone who knew Milk and lived in SF and CA during the period in the film (and worked for the No On 6 campaign) I was deeply moved by the film. It is, necessarily, a narrowing of the vision, and a hagiography of Milk, who no one would have considered to have done much more than get elected as a Gay man, which was, of course, and at the time, no small accomplishment either. Penn's performance is stunning. The film is Oscar-worthy in many ways, direction, cinematographically, acting, screenwriting. The latter is perhaps it's best achievement: it's insistant positioning of Gay people as human lives not "a lifestyle." It is a worthy and poignant biopic that comes along, like Milk, at just the right time.