I gave this a 3 my 70ish Mom gave it a 5. There were a lot of good hilarious laughs throughout. I thought that some of the Christmases were a bit long and wished they would have yelled "Mistletoe" sooner.
I think many girls that are overly obsessed with the books were disappointed because they over compared the book to the movie. Movies are "based" on the novels not exact replicas. I can envision that if Twilight does well, the sequels will have a larger budget and be longer and more in depth and possibly revisit Twilight through a Midnight Sun movie and pull in all of the "missing parts" later on in the sequel to satisfy the book fans. One can only hope!
Saw this 3 times so far and I still love it each time. So many of us have been invested in these characters for so long that we feel their happiness and their pain. It was a wonderful roller coaster ride that I wished would have never stopped.