I saw new moon and liked it, I had no expectations so the little bit of action and cool shape shifting was Really cool to me. After seeing new moon I borrowed and read eclipse and I loved it, there wasn't that much suicidal teen romance in comparison to what I've ears of the other books and the action and suspense throughout the book was great, plus Jacob is a bad ass. But this movie was nothing like the book in it's lack of suspense, little action, horrific acting and a crappy attempt at romantic scenes, and god awful attempts to be funny(honestly the only thong funny about this movie was that me and my girl couldn't atop laughing at how bad it was, especially the acting)but all that could have been forgiven if they would have done the Jasper flashback right. Jaspers telling of the newborn wars that took up atleast 100pgs of the book hadn't been watered down to a quick 2min retelling. I literally used my iPhones stopwatch during this movie to time how much action or suspense occurws during this movie and the final tally was a astonishing 12mins. 12mins! That alone is enough to keep people away from the most action packed book in the twilight series. I feel sorry for people who are expecting a big showdown with the volturi in breaking dawn.