It's certainly not as good as the book, of course, but I was unpleasantly surprised after watching this one. It was my favorite of all the books and coming off of New Moon, I went in with high expectations only to be let down. The chemistry between the characters seemed to be a lot less than New Moon and even Twilight and the acting (Kristen Stewart, in particular) was below par, which is odd because one would anticipate the acting and chemistry would improve with each movie! Anyway, I liked it, but didn't love it and certainly won't be paying to see it again in theaters...