I loved Eclipse! The new actors for Riley, Bree and Leah were great. I think Rachelle LeFevre was a much better Victoria! Too bad they didn't keep her. Other than that, it was great.
Silly movie, but the fashions are fun. The actresses are great and beautiful. I would have liked Samantha to get back with her ex model/actor, instead of just acting like a tramp. I hated Carrie's outfit at the wedding. I did enjoy Liza.
New moon is amazing. The special effects were awesome and as realistic as possible. The cast was perfect, including the new actors. The Volturi were creepy and evil as necessary. My heart really went out to Jacob, much more than when reading the book. Taylor's baby face and his great acting made it happen. I love Bella's dad. I think Kristen is very talented for her age and will only get better and better.
After the delay in the movie release, I thought they would be able to cover more of the book. How can you show a 600+ pages book in 2 1/2 hours? The actors perform well and the special effects are great.