Low story rating was because of the holes. Some things just didn't ring true enough or weren't resolved. With that said, was probably the best Superman ever for me. The special effects were stellar and very realistic. Which leads to the rough part--was so realistic at the end you felt you were there on the screen or in New York on 9/11. That was most troubling that it really made you feel what the people outside the World Trade Center must have experienced on 9/11. Not sure if this is a good thing or a bad thing but it left me a little unnerved.