Okay, so first off I should reveal (or admit) that I have read the books. Not once, or twice, but 34 times (I've read all 4 a total of 34 times)! So of course the books are ALWAYS better...until now. I really enjoyed Breaking Dawn (Pt.1) for several reasons. Firstly, it stuck to the book very well. Secondly, when it didn't stick to the book, it expanded upon it, building interesting moments that just can't be shown in a book (unless it's a picture book!). The acting was so amazing, and at times extremely realistic. You truly believe Bella is sick. There were a few "ick" factors that some of my fellow movie goers were grossed out by, but honestly...it's a vampire movie! All in all, I say it's the best in the Saga, and stands on it's own wonderfully. Go see it. Again...and again...and again!!!