I thought Breaking Dawn part 1 was pretty good at following the book, however I feel like the wolf parts could have been done to be less cheesy. I would have used subtitles for what the wolves were saying to each other telepathically rather than having them actually talk out loud. That was a little ridiculous. I did think they did a great job making Bella look awful during the pregnancy and when she "died". I like the way they did that part of it.