I love the books, read them multiple times. Eclipse the movie had so many discrepencies from the book, from the valedictorian who was Eric in the book, to the way Rosalie told Bella her story, the fight after Jacob's first kiss, to the tent scene. The fight scene was however the most disappointing Bella was still at the tent when Jacob got hurt and Jacob did not phase back immediately he had to be persuaded later that it would be better for his recovery. I did enjoy the movie better the second time around after I reread the book for the fourth time. Still looking forward to Breaking Dawn.