Ive read the books, Eclipse is the best book but this movie is the most boring. I went with my girlfriend and her friends who wore "I like men that sparkle" t-shirts and all three of them left the movie disappointed, Im talking die-hard fans here who got their tickets 3 months before the movie came out. Its too much about Edward and Jacob, not enough about the other vampires and wolves. The movie was long, boring, but the fighting scenes were incredible. Id give it 2 stars compared to New Moon.