I really enjoyed Eclipse. It stuck very close to the book, which I am fanatical about. However, the 2 parts that strayed seemed to bother me a bit. 1. They had the vampires heads/bodies shatter while fighting. In the book they must bite the body part off. Made them seem too weak. One punch and you're dead?? Not at all how it happens in the book. 2. The fight scene with Riley, Edward and victoria. When Bella draws blood to distract them from killing Edward. That didnt happen in the book. She was about to do it, put the rock to her arm, pushed and gasped cause it hurt. No blood came. But the gasp is what made them turn and look. Overall though it was amazing. These were the only two things that bothered me.