To me, it just didn't seem to move the story-line enough. . . what was there was good, but seemed like half-a-movie, instead of a whole movie. vampires and wolves can fight til the cows come home, but in the end, what changed in the lives of the characters??? not a whole lot. i expected a major change for at least one of them, but got nothing in that respect. enjoyed the dialogue between jacob and edward, in the tent. very funny. would have liked to have seen more of that.