Most people say that for the reader one who reads the book before seeing the movie is usually disappointed because of all the things that were left out. I on the other hand did read the book before seeing it opening day, but it was becasuse I read that I found the movie AMAZING! The director by far did a much better job at taking line from line and emotional feel all EXACTLY to the way the book was written. "Eclipse" was by far the best one yet and I hope that the next one will be even better. I couldn't believe how close the movie was to the book. As I was watching most of the scenes it seemed like I was reading all this in my head instead of watching it. Thats how good it was. I will say to be a respectful critic that it was a bit fast but it needed to be to get that much information. There are also back stories that WERE told. THAT made me happy! Over all a great movie. I would highly recommend seeing it. Twilight Fan or Not its a good see.