I think that this was the best out of the three. It followed pretty much with the book. I went with a friend who didn't read any of the books or watched the other two movies and she was able to follow what was going on and could tell that there were parts that referred to the other two books. I agree with everyone else about the fight scene. That was the big main event in the book and I thought they could've showed more of it in the movie. Overall it was a great movie. I would go see it again!