I read the twilight series just last month, so its still very fresh in my mind. I think all the movies have been good, i gave eclipse 4 stars only because it felt to me there could have been a few more things in the movie from the book. They can't put everything in there i understand but, just like when alice kindnaps bella and jacob show up at school unexspected and take her for the day, and in the tent, in the morning when bella wakes up and is trying to get edward to help her, the way him and jacob almost fight. and right after when jacob runs off and she send edward to get him thens she kisses him (jacob). Over all great movie !! can't wait for the next 2 :) yay ! Anyone that has watched the other movies and liked them should love it !