I am an adult fan of the Twilight Series, and I found myself disappointed with the movie adaptations of the first 2 books. David Slade, however, hit the nail on the head. Eclipse, the movie, had all of the romance, action, and tension that were such an integral part of the book. My one piece of advice is - don't listen to the critics. Eclipse was not made to win an Academy award (thank you David!) - it was made to entertain. And I for one was thoroughly entertained. It is only too bad that real men don't measure up to Edward or Jacob. Hmmm, maybe that is why the Twilight Series is so popular with adult females...