Oh how I can not even begin to describe this horrendous movie! First off, I was so excited to see this movie in theaters, but fortunately I didn't get around to seeing it in theaters but later rented in at RedBox. Thank God I only spent $1.00 on this movie, that's about all it was worth. I was so dissapointed because I am a huge fan of Channing and Amanda, also a fan of N. Sparks. But wow did they mess up on this one!! The whole story line was bad and too unrealistic. I totally agree with others on how she quickly moved on after he left for war and the ending. But for me it started sooner like the very begining how they met and fell way too fast for eachother, also it just didn't flow right, lots of choppy scenes. Also what really bothered me is how Amanda's character knew about Autism and John's dad's case but yet didn't even follow up on him or even knew that he died until John told her, yet she didn't live far away and she would always visit him. I could go on and on but one more thing was who in their right mind would send someone a letter, while at war, and break up with them...inconciderate even if they had moved on they could wait til they were home. DON't EVEN RENT IT!!!