This movie I thought was better with Jacob Black in it, because personalily Ithought that he added more action to the movie. I did notice that they cut out some scenes in the book that would really make the movie better but it was still a very good movie. At the end I thought that they could have done it better because he asked her to marry him and then it just ended with not having a pause of time to see Bella's facial expression. But i did enjoy the movie and i cannnot wait until Eclispe comes out!