I love the books...but the movies dont do them justice. I enjoyed seeing the books on the big screen, of course...but if I had to just rate New Moon as a movie...it would fall very short. I had a friend with me that has never read the books, just seen Twilight and now, New Moon. She was impressed with all the skin, but we both were dissappointed. I will still go see Eclispe because I love the books. I can only hope it is better than its predecessors.