I thought at that New Moon followed the book relatively well with only a couple errors. When I go to see a movie that has been based on a book, I look for closeness, and I got it throughout most of the movie. The cliffhanger at the end was completely different from the book and some of the scenes were wrong, but over all, it was good. I liked all of the actors portrayal of the characters and thought that they all did a good job. Hopefully Eclipse will be just as good, if not better.