The movie was engaging, but still doesn't compare to the book. It was full of action and the CG was right on, even non-Twilighters would take pleasure in the movie. Taylor was so delightful to look upon and ofcourse he was skillful in his acting, he is ideal for the character of Jacob. I would advise Edward to keep his shirt on; his skeletal corpse didn't do anything for my viewing pleasure, or the movie. I'm not sure if I am partial to the ending, it was lacking. All that action and in the last ten second, they ruined it.