Am a die-hard Twi-fan and was anticipating the BEST with Eclipse. But...though I wouldn't have missed it for the world...and enjoyed so much of it (just seeing the vamps again on the big screen)...it still left me wanting. The movie seemed choppy at times. Did think that the visuals (make-up, hair, CGI) were GREATLY improved from the previous two movies. Three cheers for that! Though...I still have a problem with the "redness" of Edward's lips. He is a vampire! Why would his lips be RED? In fact...would love the make-up on all of the Cullens to be more subtle. I will of course watch it again & again...and will certainly purchase the DVD. But....and there's that "but" again.