My husband hated it but I loved it!! It's been a while since I read the New Moon book but from what I could tell it followed close enough. It Deffinately had more emotional development between the characters than in the original Twilight movie which I felt was really lacking. You could tell they got a much bigger budget for filming on this one too! The graphics were good and had some great photography angles. Overall I loved it and will be more than likely buying when it comes out on DVD too:)