Amazingly, New Moon had the opportunity to be rather beautiful, but left me wanting more from the main chars... there was a lot of bad acting (if any at all) and I didn't care for the script.
The music choice was atrocious. I understand that the music used for the film is trying to give off the cool, offbeat, indie vibe.. but its not working. I wanted to claw my ears off at few points because the music felt and sounded so inappropriate for the scene.
With these Twilight Saga movies making as much money as they do I quite honestly expected more.
The best scene? The opening 'New Moon' sequence, the "moon" was kind of slow moving, but together the visuals and music were breathtaking.