This movie will satisfy the romantic in girls and women alike . . . it is great! Of course there is nothing like the book, but the movie did a good job at capturing Bella's broken heart and Edward's struggle to keep her safe. Jake is of course GORGEOUS! The editing could've been better and some car scene effects were a bit rough - they felt to me like there were people outside the car moving it to make it look real . . . just my opinion. But overall the movie is great!