In my opinion I thought this movie was very good. I think it was a lot better than the first because the first movie just like the books set up the story line. In Twilight they changed things around that were different from the book. In the second movie New Moon they stuck to the book more which made it a really movie. The only part I would say was a little weak was when Jacob was in Bella's bedroom and he said for her remember back to the stories he had told her. In the book he said she should guess and try and figure it out.