Chris Wentz did an awsome job and really did stick very closely to the book. The movie was visually very beautiful. I think that Kristen showed how good she really is. Taylor was good but I didn't like his take on Jacob. Rob was fab!! Loved that they showed Edward's reaction to the phone call. I still wished that they would have given more back ground story. Overall as a fan of the books I very much enjoyed it. It could have been a little more slowed done at the end but I know they have to stay within a certain running time. However I think that audiances wouldn't have minded a longer movie.