There are some inconsistencies from the book, but what "book to movie" doesn't have those? Overall, it is the best acted of the three so far~you can tell the actors have finally fully embraced their characters and their lines are smooth. Charlie, as always, is a riot! Major Jasper should have been given more lines from the first movie as he is great. And Edward~Edward is sweet and playful as well as his typical protective self but somehow even prettier than before!