I thought the director left out a lot of events from the book that I would like to see in the movie. My boy friend from a guys point of of view would have liked to see more action scenes I really thought the ending would have had more action. And it was disappointing that the main villain did not even make one physical apearance in the movie. The good side of it was the comedy was very refreshing, the graphics were very well done, the beginning left off to the previous movies ending, and it introduced a lot of new characters. If you have read the books it will definitely not fill your appetite