I have yet to read the books, so when they get to my doorstop in a few days I can do my comparison but for someone who has only seen both movies, I was left wanting more! The richness in color and effects are 100 times better in New Moon. I was at the edge of my seat, not knowing how it ends, so when it did I was left their with my jaw wide open, LITERALLY, lol! It was kinda slow for a bit, but I guess that's just how the story really goes, even in the book. I'm an Edward fan, so whenever I don't see him on screen, I felt like I wasn't watching a "Twilight" film, but then again, that's how the story progresses. A must see!