I didn't feel any connection with the characters, they seemed to lack depth. Maybe I was suppose to have already had that connection from the book, but I didn't have it. As for the fx, maybe it was my glasses and I saw in IMAX, but everything seemed a bit drab and cloudy. Ok so that's part of the dreamworld? I guess my dreams have a different color scheme.
Acting was ok, nothing special on either side for me. I think Depp stood out a bit because a lot of focus was on his facial features (was it me or were they a bunch of facial close-ups in this movie?). I kept staring at the black makeup/void on his teeth to make the gap everything Depp was on screen.
All in all I won't rent/buy/netflix it once it comes out on disc.
While I usually don't get too bothered when the plot of a movie doesn't move from a few yard radius, I felt rather cramped during this movie.
For the religious debate, I found it interesting and somewhat entertaining. Yes a bit confusing, but it was nice to see something not so good/bad or cut/dry.
The acting wasn't horrible, but the dialogue was annoying.
Overall I recommend a rental on this one and save some cash. This'll look just as good on a smaller screen.