For the new wannabe Trekkies and most of the "I've seen the whole series TV and Movie" Trekkies this was definately a 5 outta 5 flick. For the "HARD CORE" fans I think you'll find it disappointing. The Romulans were a little far fetched IMO. The power plant in the ships were also a little hmmm unbelieveable and throwing Kirk on a desolate planet?! Well I was thinking of Jack Sparrow and I was waiting for Kirk to find some Space Turtles to find his way back to Enterprise. The movie is definately for the new age of movie goers who look for non stop action and not so much plot or character development. Go see it...enjoy it and for the Hard Core well you know you want to watch it just to form your own opinions anyway.