Perhaps due to the expectations one would have for a movie with Depp, Bale & Mann, it was everything you could ask for in a great movie, but left you wanting more out of it. It never "swept" you away in that epic experience kind of way, where you walk out going, "wow!". Don't get me wrong, it is a very well crafted movie & Depp's performance is amazing. Cotillard is excellent as well & her performance was up to the task opposite Depp. Definitely go see it as it is one of the better movies this year, but it could have been so much bigger.