I think anyone who goes to see a movie that is adapted from a book and expects it to be exactly like the book is asking for disappointment. Think about it--the makers of the movie have two hours to condense this beautiful love story that enfolds nearly on a day-to-day basis. It's very difficult! I enjoyed it...but I couldn't give it 5 stars simply because I thought the acting could have been better, and I also thought that at times, the script became improvised and the improvisation was poor. But overall--it was visually stimulating and the actors fit their roles. What more can you ask for? Maybe the makers of the next movie will take a bigger risk and extend the length of the movie (i.e. Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings)? =) Go see it.