i think it could have been better but it was still good. the guy that played edward was more awkward then anything because i never really got the confidence that the real edward would be but the humans, victoria, rosalie, jacob, and carliasle did great jobs the others need work but all in all it was good. parts were different from the book so i don't realy think people have to read the book to watch the movie but they might get confused if they don't the biggest disappointment would have to be the fighting seen it just ended way to fast but the movie is still good not enough jacob though lol.