Whenever a book gets made into a movie, I always try to separate the two, especially when I see the movie. There is only so much you can fit into a 2 hour slot while staying true to the book. Overall, the movie was good and very cute and the guys were all hot, to be perfectly honest. The only thing was I felt that some of the other characters like Jasper and Alice were not as developed and really had nowhere to go. I would have loved to seen more of Alice since she is such an important figure.