This movie was really enjoyable and sweet and pretty closely done to the book, considering time constraints of a movie. The actors did a great job seeming mysterious but there voices needed to be more musical, i didnt feel that some of the romantic scenes were as breathtakingly portrayed as they were in the book. i think the lighting and sound could have been better used to portray this. the movie was great and i loved every minute of it, as someone who has already read the book. if you didnt read it, it may have been tough to really understand what was going on. but either way, i think the end definitely left you wanting to see the second one!!!