The problem with most people is that they expect the movie to be identical with the book. This is a most difficult task. The movie should capture the essence of the book and this movie does that in spades. I feel that the people cast in all of the roles were chosen because they could pull off the emotions needed. I feel the director told the story well and having read all of the books I know how the story should have gone. Edward is tortured he loves Bella and her blood is intoxicating to him. I felt that love and pain while watching the movie. Excellent movie. I enjoyed with my two daughters ages 14 and 17 yrs.