I've read all 4 books & what is done of Midnight Sun and I must say I was very pleased w/ the movie. I know Hollywood cant do everything from book to movie so I wasnt expecting every detail to be in the movie but I really loved this movie. It tries to get in as much info as possible to tell the story right. Rob played Edward really well, he was romantic, cute, but also dark. I mean come on a vampire has to have a scary side. Kristen made Bella very awkward which is what Bella is. My guy friend that came w/ me who has not read any of the books really enjoyed the movie. I cant wait for it to come out on DVD. I have seen it twice so far and will probably see it more.