I LOVE THIS MOVIE. THEY DID A GOOD JOB STICKING TO THE BOOK. I THINK ROB DID A GOOD JOB AS EDWARD. KRISTEN GOT ON MY NERVES ALITTLE AND THINK SHE COULD OF PUT A SMILE ON HER FACE ON SOME PARTS. JASPER DID A GOOD JOB, FUNNY , BEING IN PAIN. CHARLIE WAS GREAT COMIC RELIEF. COULD OF SEEN MORE OF THE CULLENS. OVER ALL GREAT MOVIE. CAN'T WAIT FOR NEW MOON. AND I THOUGHT ROB WAS GORGEOUS IN HARRY POTTER,SO YEAH HE'S THE PERFECT EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!